Kansas City in Jackson County, Missouri — The American Midwest (Upper Plains)
General Orders No. 11
A State Divided: The Civil War in Missouri
General Orders No. 11:
The Revenge of Depopulation
The building in front of you (401 Delaware Street) opened for business in the spring of 1860 as the Pacific House Hotel, one of Kansas City's most up-to-date hotels. During the war years, the building was partially taken over by Union military authorities, and by 1863, was serving as the headquarters for the District of the Border under the command of Brig. Gen. Thomas Ewing, Jr. It was from his office in this building that Ewing issued the controversial General Orders No. 11 on Aug. 25, 1863.
General Orders No. 11 required that all inhabitants of the western Missouri border counties of Jackson, Cass, Bates, and the northern half of Vernon not living within one mile of specified military posts vacate their homes within 15 days (Sept. 9, 1863). Those citizens who could establish their loyalty to the Union with the commanding officer of the military station nearest their place of residence would be permitted to move to any military station in the District of the Border or to any part of Kansas except the counties on the eastern border of that state. Persons who failed to prove their loyalty were to move out of the district completely or be subject to military punishment.
General Orders. No. 11 is regarded by historians as one of the harshest measures
With too few troops available to eliminate or neutralize the guerrilla menace, Union strategists pursued the alternative policy of retaliation against the civilian population that harbored the guerrillas. In early August, Ewing wrote his superior, Gen. John M. Schofield, stating that since two-thirds of the families in western Missouri were kin to the guerrillas and were "actively engaged in feeding, clothing and sustaining them," several hundred of these families should be transported to Arkansas. This plan, embodied in General Orders
Immediately, there arose in Kansas a clamor for revenge. Radical Kansas senator, James H. Lane, threatened to "lay waste to the border counties of Missouri and exterminate the disloyal people." Ewing was under tremendous pressure to take immediate action. His response was General Orders No. 11.
While perhaps less stringent than unrestrained vengeance by Kansas "Jayhawkers," General Orders No. 11 was, nonetheless, terrible enough in its own right. It caused great hardship and suffering on the civilian populations of the effected counties who were given just 15 days to vacate their homes and farms. There were descriptions of "refugees passing through...ill clad, often times barefooted, leaving their only shelter, and their only means of sustenance during the approaching winter - the crops now maturing - in numerous cases without money to buy food or pay rent going they know not wither." Long moving wagon trains of exiles in vehicles of every description drawn by teams of every variety, except "good ones," made their way out of the region. One federal officer declared, "It is heart sickening to see what I have seen...A desolated country and women and children, some of them almost naked. Some on foot and some in old wagons. Oh, God. What a sight to see in this once happy and peaceable
Perhaps the worst feature of the depopulation was that Kansas soldiers were used to assist in the enforcement of the order. These vengeance-minded troops did not overlook such a splendid opportunity to punish Missourians. Ewing's intention was that only hay and grain should be destroyed, but the Kansans ignored these instructions. Several men suspected of aiding Quantrill were summarily shot, and much pillaging of livestock and household valuables occurred. So many barns and houses were destroyed that in some areas the only standing structures were the charred chimneys of residences put to the torch. Such remainders came to be known as "Jennison's monuments," so named after Charles Jennison, one of the most notorious of the Kansas Jayhawkers. The devastation was so complete in Cass and Bates counties that the region was known for many years as the "Burnt District."
Although accurate figures do not exist, it is generally assumed that some 20,000 people were forced to evacuate their homes by General Orders No. 11. In Bates County, hardly a single family remained - the county became an empty wilderness - while in Cass County only 600 inhabitants were allowed to remain in a county that before the Civil War had a
While most hard-line Unionists considered General Orders No. 11 a military necessity to curtail guerrilla activity, the order aroused a storm of protest among moderate and conservative Missouri Unionists who regarded it as "inhuman, unmanly and barbarous." The best known of these critics was the celebrated Missouri artist, George Caleb Bingham. He had warned Ewing during a stormy meeting in the Pacific Hotel that if Ewing issued the order Bingham would make him "infamous with pen and brush as far as I am able." For the next 16 years, until his death, Bingham availed himself of every opportunity to assail Ewing for issuing the notorious order. He executed two versions of a painting entitled "Order No. 11," which depicted Ewing on horseback impassively presiding over a dismal scene of senseless murder and pillage committed on innocent civilians by heartless and bloodthirsty Kansas troops.
The public outcry against the harshness of the order soon led to a relaxing of its severe provisions. On Nov. 20, 1863, Gen. Ewing issued General Orders No. 20, which provided for a limited resettlement of the depopulated district by individuals who could meet a strict test for loyalty. In January, 1864, the District of the Border was reorganized and placed under command of Gen. Egbert B. Brown, who was one of the critics of General Orders. No. 11.
The demise of General Orders No. 11 was one example of the inability of Union military authorities to devise a workable anti-guerrilla strategy. In 1864, Quantrill's band was back in Missouri, concentrating their operations north of the Missouri River in the central section of the state where they spread terror among Union sympathizers and continued to elude federal efforts to exterminate them.
Lacking the troop strength necessary for a massive campaign against the guerrillas, commanders were also unable to take effective action against the civilian population that sustained them. Public opinion simply would not support such drastic measures as the depopulation of an entire region. Still, as historian James McPherson has observed, such actions as General Orders No. 11 foreshadowed the total war practices that would be used in the eastern theater of the war during its final bloody year. Events in Missouri helped to move the federal high command to the conviction later put into words by Gen. William T. Sherman that "We are not only fighting hostile armies, but a hostile people," who must be made to "feel the hard hand of war."
Erected by Missouri Department of Natural Resources.
Location. 39° 6.529′ N, 94° 35.068′ W. Marker is in Kansas City, Missouri, in Jackson County. Marker is on Delaware Street near 4th Street, on the right when traveling south. Touch for map. Marker is in this post office area: Kansas City MO 64105, United States of America.
Other nearby markers. At least 8 other markers are within walking distance of this marker. The Pacific House (a few steps from this marker); J. P. Campbell & Company Building (within shouting distance of this marker); W. H. Morgan & Company (within shouting distance of this marker); Tootle, Hanna & Leach Dry Goods (within shouting distance of this marker); Kansas City's Original Board of Trade (about 300 feet away, measured in a direct line); City Market (about 400 feet away); Richards & Conover Hardware Company Building (about 400 feet away); Oldham Hotel (approx. 0.2 miles away). Touch for a list and map of all markers in Kansas City.
Also see . . .
1. Order No. 11 and Civil War on the Border, by Albert Castel (1963). (Submitted on March 31, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania.)
2. General Order No. 11. (Submitted on March 31, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania.)
3. Order No. 11 Text. (Submitted on March 31, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania.)
4. George Caleb Bingham's Painting, Order No. 11". (Submitted on March 31, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania.)
Categories. • Disasters • Patriots & Patriotism • Settlements & Settlers • War, US Civil •
Credits. This page was last revised on June 16, 2016. This page originally submitted on March 31, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania. This page has been viewed 772 times since then and 19 times this year. Photos: 1, 2. submitted on April 2, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania. 3. submitted on March 31, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania. 4, 5, 6. submitted on April 2, 2012, by William Fischer, Jr. of Scranton, Pennsylvania.