3 entries match your criteria. Historical Markers and War Memorials in Cincinnatus Clickable Map of Cortland County, New York and Immediately Adjacent Jurisdictions image/svg+xml 2019-10-06 U.S. Census Bureau, Abe.suleiman; Lokal_Profil; HMdb.org; J.J.Prats/dc:title> https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Usa_counties_large.svg Cortland County, NY (55) Broome County, NY (56) Cayuga County, NY (151) Chenango County, NY (83) Madison County, NY (74) Onondaga County, NY (177) Tioga County, NY (48) Tompkins County, NY (48) CortlandCounty(55) Cortland County (55) BroomeCounty(56) Broome County (56) CayugaCounty(151) Cayuga County (151) ChenangoCounty(83) Chenango County (83) MadisonCounty(74) Madison County (74) OnondagaCounty(177) Onondaga County (177) TiogaCounty(48) Tioga County (48) TompkinsCounty(48) Tompkins County (48) Cincinnatus, New York and Vicinity ▶ Cortland County (55) ▶ Broome County (56) ▶ Cayuga County (151) ▶ Chenango County (83) ▶ Madison County (74) ▶ Onondaga County (177) ▶ Tioga County (48) ▶ Tompkins County (48) Touch name on list to highlight map location.Touch blue arrow, or on map, to go there. GEOGRAPHIC SORT1► New York (Cortland County), Cincinnatus — Bentley Family — On Taylor Valley Road (County Route 600) 1 mile east of Hawley Woods Road (County Route 159A), on the right when traveling west. 2► New York (Cortland County), Cincinnatus — 241 — Early Sawmill — 3► New York (Cortland County), Cincinnatus — 584 — Reid Ice Cream — On New York State Route 26 0.1 miles south of New York State Route 23, on the right.