Winfield in Putnam County, West Virginia — The American South (Appalachia)
Historic Hoge House
— River to Ridges Heritage Trail —
Planting Roots in Putnam County
James William Hoge was born on April 9, 1830 in Staunton, Augusta County, Virginia to Reverend Peter C. and Sallie Kerr Hoge. He studied law and was admitted to the bar at age 20 in 1850, later moving to Winfield in 1852. Hoge wed Sarah Wright of Charleston on May 19, 1857 and the couple had 11 children, 8 of whom survived to adulthood. In the summer of 1882, Hoge suffered from a liver ailment which caused his death on August 12th at the young age of 52.
“Few equals” — James Hoge and the Law
Receiving a license to practice law before his 21st birthday, Hoge embarked on a prestigious legal career. He partnered with an experienced Charleston attorney to expand the practice into Mason County and the recently created Putnam County. After just a few years in his new home, Hoge was elected prosecuting attorney for the county, a position which he was re-elected to multiple times. In 1867, he was appointed to the 11th Circuit Court in West Virginia to fill a vacancy for a year and a half. Although some citizens opposed his politics, 42 lawyers including
Upon the death of Putnam County’s first clerk Hart Hills Forbes in 1856, James W. Hoge buried his brother-in-law in a newly created cemetery. Additional burials would include James and Sarah Hoge, 8 of their 11 children, Sarah’s parents, and one of James’ brothers. Across the 1870s and 1880s, 7 of Dr. S. B. Thompson’s patients, including his wife and daughter, were buried in the cemetery. Mrs. Thompson’s death was listed as “a sore throat,” which may
North? South? Neutral?
As the sole representative for Putnam County at the Virginia Secession Convention in April 1861, Judge Hoge voted against Virginia leaving the Union. After that vote passed, he left and did not further participate in the convention. Even though he had been commissioned in the Virginia Militia, Hoge did not serve the Confederacy nor did he participate in the formation of West Virginia or support the United States. He “gave us not one word of cheer or comfort,” wrote one citizen. Another called Hoge an “artful dodger” who rescued “some notorious rebels [civilians] from the custody of our Soldiers, who had been arrested for carrying rebel mail and giving information to the rebels.” After an 1864 skirmish in Winfield, the body of the only Confederate casualty was left with Hoge who had the young man properly buried expecting the family to claim the body shortly. Hoge had “southern sympathies” according to his grandson, but there is no clear evidence that James W. Hoge supported either side during the Civil War. He is best characterized as neutral.
Judge Hoge’s Career
• 1850: Admitted to the bar
• 1855-1863: Private Practice with Andrew Parks
• 1856-1867: Putnam County Prosecuting Attorney
• 1859: Commissioned Colonel 181st Virginia Militia
• 1861: Putnam County delegate to the Virginia Secession Convention
• 1867-1868: Appointed 11th Circuit Court Judge
• 1869-1874: Elected 11th Circuit Court Judge
• 1870s: Putnam County Superintendent of Schools (exact dates unknown)
• 1874-1882: Private Practice
The Historic Hog House is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the United States’ official list of places worthy of historic preservation, for local significance. It derives significance from association with Judge James W. Hoge and as a vernacular example of Federalist architecture characterized by stepped side gables, interior chimneys, and a decorative brick cornice.
The Historic Hoge House
A single story brick house was built approximately 1000 feet from its current site in 1838 on Lot #8 in what would become Winfield, West Virginia. Charles Brown had the house built and his son Tallyrand Brown occupied it upon its completion. On May 22,1848 the first session of the Putnam County Court was held in Tallyrand Brown’s house, now the Historic Hoge House. Charles Brown willed the house to Tallyrand Brown in 1849 who sold it to John Bowyer in 1852, Bower rented the premises to James W. Hoge in 1855 and sold it to him in 1857. Judge Hoge lived in this building for 25 years and his wife remained here for another 32 years. One of their daughters, known as Aunt Birdie, lived in the house until 1947 and the Hoge family owned the property until 2002; 145 years of ownership in the same family!
Architectural Terms and Features
• Federal Style — An American construction design, 1780-1840, noted for the use of symmetry, decorative cornices, and windows with double-hung sashes.
• Stepped Gables — A gable is the end of a wall that encloses the roof. Typically gables are triangular in shape, whereas this gable has a series of steps that resemble a stairway rather than a triangle.
• Decorative Brick Cornice — A cornice is the feature that appears just below the roofline. This cornice contains four rows of brick with each higher row projecting further outward than the row below it. The top row has brick with the short end projecting even further outward.
• Flemish Bond — Describes the brick pattern of alternating stretchers (long side facing outward) and headers (short side facing outward).
• Double-hung sash windows — The window has two movable parts, both bottom and top. The windows shown here are referred to as 9 over 9 (counting the individual panes in each sash). The number of panes in the original windows is unknown.
• Side Lights — A panel of lights appearing next to the door.
Erected by Rivers to Ridges Heritage Trail.
Topics. This historical marker is listed in these topic lists: Architecture • Government & Politics • Notable Buildings • Settlements & Settlers.
Location. 38° 31.937′ N, 81° 53.38′ W. Marker is in Winfield, West Virginia, in Putnam County. Marker is at the intersection of Courthouse Drive and Emergency Lane / Sabre Street, on the right when traveling south on Courthouse Drive. It is behind the courthouse. Touch for map. Marker is in this post office area: Winfield WV 25213, United States of America. Touch for directions.
Other nearby markers. At least 8 other markers are within 2 miles of this marker, measured as the crow flies. The Civil War in Putnam County (about 400 feet away, measured in a direct line); Putnam County War Memorial (approx. 0.2 miles away); Winfield / Battle of Winfield (approx. 0.2 miles away); Red House Shoals / Civil War Action (approx. 0.9 miles away); Coal Mining in Putnam County (approx. 1.8 miles away); A Park for the Coal Miner (approx. 1.8 miles away); Andrew & Charles Lewis March (approx. 1.8 miles away); George Washington (approx. 1.8 miles away). Touch for a list and map of all markers in Winfield.
More about this marker. This interpretive panel contains a number of illustrations:
• A portrait of James William Hoge
• A photograph of the Hoge Cemetery, which can be reached via a footpath behind the house
• A copy of the Parks and Hoge Business Card
• A copy of Judge James W. Hoge’s Election Certificate
• A photograph of the Hoge House, circa 1900
• A photograph of the Hoge House today
Credits. This page was last revised on May 20, 2020. It was originally submitted on August 1, 2019, by J. J. Prats of Powell, Ohio. This page has been viewed 142 times since then and 43 times this year. Last updated on August 6, 2019, by Michael Keller of Charleston, West Virginia. Photos: 1, 2, 3. submitted on August 1, 2019, by J. J. Prats of Powell, Ohio.