Huntingdon Valley in Bryn Athyn in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania — The American Northeast (Mid-Atlantic)
Train Crash Claims 26 Lives
The cause of the accident was the failure of the crew on northbound Train 151 (to Newtown) to confirm and obey a written train order issued to them at the Bryn Athyn station. The crew did not realize that they were to take the siding and let not one but two, southbound trains (Numbers 154 and 156) pass before resuming their trip to Newtown. Train 151 left the siding after the first train had cleared the line but while train 156 was still heading south on the single track line.
The accident occurred at the worst possible spot on the rail line - on a blind curve through a deep rock cut. The fact that the passenger-carrying cars were of wooden construction contributed to the high number of fatalities, for after the engines collided, the passenger cars were set on fire by the hot coals from the fireboxes of the two steam locomotives. Most of the dead were those who were trapped in the wreckage and could not escape the flames.
The inaccessibility of the site and the snow on the ground that morning made the job of reaching the wreck difficult. Local doctors were summoned by the Bethayres telephone operator. A number of area fire companies responded including Bryn Athyn, Hatboro, Willow Grove, Huntingdon Valley, Southampton and Jenkintown. Many of the more seriously injured were taken to Abington Memorial Hospital.
In February 1922 at the county courthouse in Norristown, the engineer and the conductor of the northbound Train 151 were tried for criminal negligence in failing to follow railroad rules. A jury found them guilty but recommended mercy. The judge sentenced the two men to jail terms. However, in 2 months they were pardoned by the Governor and the Board of Pardons received 30,000 signatures of citizens pleading for mercy in the case.
As a result of this accident, the Interstate Commerce Commission directed the Philadelphia & Reading Railroad and all other U. S. railroads to commence replacing wooden passenger-carrying cars with those of all-steel construction. Also, as the use of a manual train-signalling system was a contributing factor in the crash, the railroad was directed to install an automatic block signal system. Many of the signal masts from this system still stand along the right of way.
This site has since been referred to as Death Gulch. A monument at the North and Southampton Reformed Church in Churchville honors a number of those killed in the accident.
Erected by Old York Road Historical Society.
Topics. This historical marker is listed in these topic lists: Disasters • Railroads & Streetcars. A significant historical date for this entry is December 5, 1921.
Location. 40° 8.83′ N, 75° 4.646′ W. Marker is in Bryn Athyn, Pennsylvania, in Montgomery County. It is in Huntingdon Valley. Marker can be reached from Creek Road. Marker can be seen only by following the Pennypack Trail on foot or bicycle. Park either at the Byberry Road parking lot at 1750 Byberry road and head South or in Bryn Athyn at 999 Fetters Mill Rd and head north. Touch for map. Marker is in this post office area: Huntingdon Valley PA 19006, United States of America. Touch for directions.
Other nearby markers. At least 8 other markers are within 2 miles of this marker, measured as the crow flies. Glencairn (approx. one mile away); Bryn Athyn Cathedral (approx. 1.1 miles away); Bryn Athyn Historic District (approx. 1.2 miles away); a different marker also named Bryn Athyn Cathedral (approx. 1.2 miles away); Milk Platform (approx. 1.2 miles away); Harold F. Pitcairn (approx. 1˝ miles away); Welcome to Huntingdon Valley Station (approx. 1.8 miles away); All Aboard for Valley Falls (approx. 1.8 miles away). Touch for a list and map of all markers in Bryn Athyn.
Credits. This page was last revised on February 23, 2023. It was originally submitted on February 19, 2023, by Seva Zaslavsky of Maplewood, New Jersey. This page has been viewed 645 times since then and 104 times this year. Photos: 1, 2, 3, 4. submitted on February 19, 2023, by Seva Zaslavsky of Maplewood, New Jersey. • Bill Pfingsten was the editor who published this page.