York in York County, Pennsylvania — The American Northeast (Mid-Atlantic)
Were the Articles a success?
Yes…
The Articles gave the fledgling nation what it needed at the time it was written - a political compromise that allowed the brave young union to fund and win a war.
But at war's end in 1783, the Articles' loose framework and the compromises in the agreement did not serve the evolving needs on an ongoing government.
Growing dissatisfaction with the Articles led to demands for amendments and, eventually, the 1787 Constitutional Convention. Elements of the Articles were copied directly into the United States Constitution. Agreements forged in York stand to this day as evidence of the enduring value of the hard bargains struck in York in 1777.
and No…
"But the confederation itself is defective and requires to be altered; It is neither fit for war nor peace. The idea of an uncontrollable sovereignty in each state over its internal police [militia] will defeat the other powers given to Congress and make our union feeble and precarious.... The confederation gives the states individually too much influence in the affairs of the army. They should have nothing to do with it. The entire formation and disposal of our military forces ought to belong to Congress....
"The confederation too gives the power of the purse too intirely to the state legislatures. It should provide perpetual funds in the disposal of Congress - by a land tax, poll tax, or the like. All imposts upon commerce ought to be laid by Congress and appropriated to their use, for without certain revenues, a government can have no power; That power, which holds the purse strings absolutely, must rule."
Alexander Hamilton (New York) to James Duane (New York), September 3, 1780
"The distinction of the individual States to yield competent powers to Congress for the Federal Government — their unreasonable jealousy [distrust] of that body & of one another — & the disposition which seems to pervade each, of being all-wise & all-powerful within itself, will, if there is not a change in the system, be our downfall as a Nation. This is as clear to me as the A. B. C.; & I think we have opposed Great Britain & have arrived at the present state of peace & independency, to very little purpose, if we cannot conquer our own prejudices."
George Washington to Benjamin Harrison (Governor of Virginia), January 18, 1784
Erected 2026.
Topics. This historical marker is listed in this topic list: Government & Politics. A significant historical date for this entry is January 18, 1784.
Location. 39° 57.763′ N, 76° 43.97′ W. Marker is in York, Pennsylvania, in York County. It is at the intersection of West Philadelphia Street (Pennsylvania Route 74/462) and North Pershing Avenue, on the right when traveling west on West Philadelphia Street. Touch for map. Marker is at or near this postal address: 121 N Pershing Ave, York PA 17401, United States of America. Touch for directions.
Regionally, this marker is in South-Central Pennsylvania, specifically in Pennsylvania Dutch Country, in the Susquehanna Valley, and in Greater Harrisburg. It is also in the American Northeast and in the Mid-Atlantic. Globally, it is in North America, the Western Hemisphere, the Western World, and the Anglosphere. Historically, it finds itself in what was once the Haudenosaunee (Iroquois) Confederacy and also one of the original Thirteen Colonies.
Other nearby markers. At least 8 other markers are within walking distance of this marker: Benjamin Franklin's response (here, next to this marker); Amazingly Congress agreed to agree. (here, next to this marker); The Declaration of Independence (here, next to this marker); The war rages on. (here, next to this marker); We declared independence. (here, next to this marker); British troops threaten Philadelphia. (here, next to this marker); We need a government but not a king. (here, next to this marker); Welcome to Hard Bargains 1777. (here, next to this marker). Touch for a list and map of all markers in York.
Credits. This page was last revised on November 16, 2026. It was originally submitted on November 16, 2026, by Devry Becker Jones of Washington, District of Columbia. This page has been viewed 5 times since then. Photos: 1, 2. submitted on November 16, 2026, by Devry Becker Jones of Washington, District of Columbia.

