Newark in Licking County, Ohio — The American Midwest (Great Lakes)
Honoring Carl Etherington
December 6, 1892 – July 8, 1910
Etherington shot the owner of an illegal saloon in self-defense. Later that day he was forcibly removed by a mob through the Licking County Jail’s north side door He was beaten and then hanged from a telegraph pole on the southeast corner of the square.
Deputy Marshal Carl Etherington’s death has been recognized as a line of duty death by the following organizations: National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Fund • Ohio Peace Officers Memorial • Officer Down Memorial Page.
Topics. This historical marker is listed in this topic list: Law Enforcement.
Location. 40° 3.378′ N, 82° 24.088′ W. Marker is in Newark, Ohio, in Licking County. Marker is at the intersection of East Canal Street and South Third Street, on Touch for map. Marker is at or near this postal address: 46 S 3rd St, Newark OH 43055, United States of America. Touch for directions.
Other nearby markers. At least 8 other markers are within walking distance of this marker. Licking County Sheriff’s Residence & Jail (a few steps from this marker); Congressional Medal of Honor Recipients (about 600 feet away, measured in a direct line); The Donald D. Hill County Administration Building (about 600 feet away); Early Transportation in Newark (approx. 0.2 miles away); Soldiers' and Sailors' Memorial Building (approx. 0.2 miles away); "Double Arrow" Wrought Iron Fence (approx. 0.2 miles away); The John W. Alford Building (approx. 0.2 miles away); McCune-Stimson House (approx. 0.2 miles away). Touch for a list and map of all markers in Newark.
1. Blind Tiger Raider
Deputy Etherington is referred to as a “blind tiger raider" in the following newspaper article. “Blind tiger” was an Americanism chiefly of the Southern and Midland United States, for a place where alcoholic beverages are sold illegally. A speakeasy. Also called in places a “blind pig.”
— Submitted May 28, 2018.
2. Article in The Springfield Sun of Springfield, Kentucky, on Wednesday,
The Lynching Tragedy in Ohio.
The Sheriff’s Neglect Responsible For The Lynching of Detective Carl M. Etherington, Son of Hartwell Etherington, of Willisburg.
Body Brought To Willisburg For Burial.
The dastardly and cowardly lynching of young Etherington at Newark, O, recently calls for the most searching investigation by the authorities. This Ohio town has long been classed as a “tough” place. Law and order has been ignored to an anarchistic degree, and it is to be hoped that the leaders in this atrocious crime will speedily be brought to justice. Following is an account of the affair:
Newark, O., July 9. — Fully 100 people of this town, unmasked, last night aided in the brutal lynching of Carl Etherington, an anti-saloon Detective. A grand jury investigation of the affair has been ordered and the authorities have caused it to be known that such an investigation will be made as soon as the grand jury shall next convene.
Etherington, who was a native of Willisburg, Washington county, Ky., was employed by the State Anti-Saloon League as a blind tiger raider, was lynched last night at 10:35 o’clock after a day of almost continuous rioting. The doors of the Licking county jail were battered down and Etherington was dragged from his cell. He was shot, kicked, and struck on the head with a hammer before the street was reached, and the finish followed quickly. He was only seventeen years of age.
Etherington early in the evening confessed he killed Wilham Howard, proprietor of the “Last Chance” restaurant and former chief of police, in a raid of alleged “speak oasis,” in a raiding scuffle at 1:30 o’clock yesterday afternoon, and narrowly escaped lynching at that time. When news from the hospital passed over the city, at 9 o’clock last night, the fury of the mob took definite form. Large battering rams were directed upon the doors of the jail, and the deputies were powerless. The doors fell after nearly an hour’s attack.
Etherington was dragged through the streets to the courthouse square and hanged to a tree in the courthouse yard. The horrible affair was witnessed by about 5,000 men, women and children.
It is believed that Etherington asked for permission to make a statement to the mob, and as he attempted to speak somebody struck him a vicious blow on top of the head with a hammer, felling him to the ground, and this blow is believed to have killed him.
Adjutant General Weybrecht says Licking county officials, particularly Sheriff William Linke, are responsible for the lynching here of Detective Carl Etherington, the Kentuckian, who shot former police chief Howard in the blind tiger raid. He has so reported to Gov. Harmon. “The lynching could easily have been prevented,” says General Weybrecht. “The established fact that the mob worked at the jail for two hours tells the story of negligence. If troops had been called for when they should have been, the State of Ohio would not now be disgraced.”
Sheriff Linke did not call out the Newark Company of the Ohio Nation Guard, of the Fourth Regiment. Capt. Priest says he was informed that it was not even necessary to have men at the armory in case of emergency.
The Eubanks anti-mob law, passed at the last session of the Legislature, provides the immediate suspension of the sheriff in case he does not protect prisoners in his custody. Suspension is followed by a hearing before the Governor.
The Governor has suspended the mayor, chief of police and the police captain. New officers were appointed and arrests immediately followed.
The remains of Carl Etherington reached here Sunday night at 8:25, and were met at the train by a large crowd most of whom had gathered to pay a last tribute of respect to the dead and to manifest their sympathy for his family. Many had accompanied the youth’s father, Hartwell Etherington, from his home near Willisburg. Amidst the most pathetic surroundings the coffin was opened for the purpose of identification, the grief of the father being tragic as he knelt by the open coffin and recognized in the battered and mutilated contents his son.
The remains were immediately taken to the Etherington home, near Willisburg, where they remained until the next day, when the funeral was held at the Christian Church, Rev. Jesse Grubbs conducting the services. It is estimated that the crowd in attendance numbered between 2,000 and 3,000 people, probably the largest number that ever attended a funeral in this county.
For hours after the services the people stood around in groups discussing the horror of the tragedy and expressing their sympathy for the family, especially the mother, who has been in a critical condition since her son was killed. Indeed the bereaved parents have the sympathy of all who have heard of the cruel murder of their son, a number of telegrams of condolence having come from a distance.
— Submitted May 28, 2018.
Credits. This page was last revised on May 28, 2018. It was originally submitted on May 28, 2018, by J. J. Prats of Powell, Ohio. This page has been viewed 103 times since then and 21 times this year. Photos: 1, 2, 3. submitted on May 28, 2018, by J. J. Prats of Powell, Ohio.