Chaffee County Jail

Photographed by Cosmos Mariner, July 22, 2025

1. Chaffee County Jail Marker

Touch for directions.

Valley,

Divide.

West.

Click or scan to see
this page online

America,

Mountains,

Hemisphere,

World,

Anglosphere.

From the National Register Nomination prepared by Jeanine Linner, 11/6/1978:
Located on the northeast corner of East Main and Court streets in Buena Vista, the Chaffee County Courthouse and Jail Building Complex consists of two structures that reflect the Italian Villa style of architecture. Both buildings lie in close proximity to one another. The larger structure, the Courthouse, faces south towards East Main,

Photographed by Cosmos Mariner, July 22, 2025

2. 1882 Chaffee County Jail (south/front elevation)

The marker is mounted at eye-level on the left side of the south entrance.

while the much smaller Jail lies to the west along Court Street.
The Jail has two stories and has three bays in each of the south (main), east, and west sides. Like the Courthouse, it has a one-story wing projecting from the north facade. This addition has five bays on both the east and west sides, none on the north, but it converts an essentially square building into a rectangular one.
The events that brought the Complex into being began in 1880 when the state legislature created Chaffee County out of Lake County, site of the great mining camp of Leadville. At first, Chaffee County had its seat and court in Granite, a few miles north of Buena Vista, but late in 1880 the voters decided to award Buena Vista the right to have the permanent county seat. Granite, however, was reluctant to abide by the decision of the electorate, but on a night in 1881 some men from Buena Vista stole into Granite under cover of darkness and with an engine and flatcar spirited the county records to Buena Vista. With the town now established as the county seat, the commissioners contracted with Mr. E. Fisher to erect a suitable courthouse and jail. Fisher

Photographed by Cosmos Mariner, July 22, 2025

3. Buena Vista School District R-31 Administration Building

(mounted near southwest corner)
Formerly the Chaffee County Jail
Originally constructed 1882
Remodeled September 1985

was experienced in this work, having built a courthouse in Canon City for Fremont County. Why he selected this particular architectural style remains unknown, but in 1882 he completed both structures at the cost of $50,000 for the Courthouse, $15,000 for the Jail.
From this time forward, the Complex played a large role in Buena Vista. For many years the structures housed the county records, served as the seat of county government, and administered justice in civil and criminal cases. In 1928, however, the voters decided to remove the county seat to Salida, and after this, the Complex remained closed for some years, but when the local school district needed more space in a time of growing enrollment, it used the Courthouse for classes until new schools could be built. The buildings in the Complex then stood abandoned until the local citizenry decided to convert them into a museum and space for local meetings.

Excerpt:  The Chaffee County Courthouse and Jail Buildings in Buena Vista, Colorado, were listed on the National Register of Historic Places

Photographed by Cosmos Mariner, July 22, 2025

4. 1882 Chaffee County Jail (west elevation)

The iron jail bars are all still in place over the windows in this section of the building!

in 1979. The courthouse is a two-story five-bay brick building, with brick laid in stretcher bond, on an ashlar foundation. The jail is a smaller building. Both were built in 1882. A different Chaffee County Courthouse, built in Salida in 1929 was designed by architect Walter DeMordaunt, after the county voted to move the courthouse to Salida.

Photographed by Cosmos Mariner, July 22, 2025

5. 1882 Chaffee County Jail (southwest elevation)

Today this former jail houses the Buena Vista School District R-31 Administration offices.

Photographed by Cosmos Mariner, July 22, 2025

6. 1882 Chaffee County Courthouse (south/front elevation)

Today this building houses the Buena Vista Heritage Museum. It is adjacent to (southeast of) the jail building. The two buildings are jointly listed on the National Register.

From the National Register Nomination:  The Courthouse is made of brick set in courses of stretcher bond over a foundation of coursed ashlar. The building has two stories. The main or south facade has five bays as do both the east and west sides, but on the north is a one-story, rectangular wing added sometime after the original construction; it has a somewhat different architectural style and is rather unobtrusive, yet it has converted what was a square structure into a rectangular one. The south, east, and west facades all have a projecting central bay topped by a pediment with a decorated tympanum. The structure has a low hipped roof topped in the center by a sexagonal cupola. The secondary elements give the Courthouse its distinctive architectural character. The tall, narrow windows are all two-sashed and double-hung, those on the projections being clustered in twos and threes. The openings on the first story are flat and decorated with a flat label; those on the second story are segmental and decorated with a segmental label. All the windows have lug sills. The main doorway also has a segmental label which lies above the architrave with a transom and double-leafed door. All the building corners, including those of the projections, are graced with quoins. At the roof line the eaves display a cornice that is boxed with frieze, and consoles. The cupola is topped by a decorative weathervane.