Mid Island on Staten Island in Richmond County, New York — The American Northeast (Mid-Atlantic)
History of Lake Cemetery
The Old Clove Baptist Church removed from Clove road at Richmond Road and relocated to Willowbrook Road about 1840. Soon a church building was erected as a meeting place for the North Shore Baptist Church and stood on the edge of a farm owned by Ann and Joseph Lake, who specified all the land surrounding the building should be used as a cemetery. It is from this couple that the Lake Cemetery derives its name. The title to all the cemetery land and considerably more, is derived through a deed from John Wright to Joseph Lake, dated February 8, 1837 and recorded on January 25, 1842.
The original section of Lake Cemetery was known as the old Burying Ground of the First Baptist Church of Graniteville. IT begins at a point on Willowbrook Road and 350 feet south of Richmond Avenue (now Port Richmond Avenue). It occupies a lot on the west side of Willowbrook Road, in dimensions about 41 x 104 feet. The first recorded burial stone is of John son of Rebecca and Cornilius Van Name who died on January 26, 1835. There is some indication that this Van Name plot was originally located in the Dutch Reformed Church/Cemetery in Port Richmond. In the old section is a large underground marble vault of the Reverend White and his family.
Lake Cemetery is non-sectarian. A complete burial map and all of the original records of the cemetery does not survive. The burial records for Lake Cemetery is a combination of one original book, undertaker records and VLD grave stone study of 1922. This list can be found in part of the Richmond County Genealogy website or by visiting Friends of Abandoned Cemeteries, Inc. site.
The cemetery is approximately 2.8 acres in total size.
History of Lake Cemetery Continued
At the end of the 19th century, Italian emigration was on the rise. Many of the new immigrants settled in the Port Richmond, Elm Park and Graniteville areas. A large unused section of Lake Cemetery became known as Silvie's Cemetery, named after the Silvie Funeral Home. This area is generally known to be by the fence on the outer boarders of the cemetery. Mots of the Staten Island Italian immigrants buried at this site had split with the Catholic Church and established Methodists/Episcopal churches. Prior 1950 Catholics were prohibited from burial in non-Catholic cemeteries; however, Lake Cemetery has several Catholic burials for reasons known to the cemetery association and the families.
The old Church building has been remodeled several times over the past 174 years and by the turn of the 20th century the Baptist group had given over its use to the Graniteville Literary Society, most of whose members were Methodists. The congregation of Graniteville Church was organized on November 6, 1908, principally by members of the Union Sunday School class which hadmet in the community for many years. It was supported by its Port Richmond neighbor Grace Methodist Church.
Today, Lake Cemetery is owned by the Lake Cemetery Association but managed and maintained by the Friends of Abandoned Cemeteries, Inc.
List of Veterans buried at Lake Cemetery
Civil War World War I
Achilles, Henry - 41st NY Cirma, Domenico - 327th NY Burton, William - 59th NY Braxton, Robert - US Navy - USS Brandywine Crowley, Clarence G. - PFC18DEPSVG ASCNY Brinkley, John - 132 NY & US Navy Full Corporal Davis, Theodore - 367th NY, 92nd Div Bunn, Ellis Albert - 6th NY Light Artillery Decker, David L. - 2nd Pioneer NY MP Decker, Abraham - 82nd NY POW DeRosa, Francesco - 73rd NY INfantry Decker, Samuel W. 158 NY Hall, Thomas - Indiana Decker, Simon Van Name - 82nd NY Klein, George L. Gassed Earl Emeline - Nurse - Wounded Luciano, Ralph J. - 308th NY Bugler Earl, Henry - Veterinarian Lagomarcino, Alfred J. - F57 NY Artillery Elms, Charles I. - 132nd NY Norburgh George - 103rd Inf. 26 Div. Elms, Daniel - 156th NY Norman, Russell - 308th NY - Gassed Emmet, A Piccioni, Vincent - Private 64 Co. 153DB Eveland, Theodore - 129th PA Prine, Wilbur - 367th NY 92nd Div. Favreau, Rudolph - 20th Ill, Musician Robinson, Edward Gillies, Duncan - 5th Maryland Van Pelt, Clarence O. - 28th AERO Hoffman, Charles - 13th Ohio Van Pelt, Percy - Private - 26th Engineer Holman, Napoleon Bonaparte - 2nd Ohio Wallace, James H. USNR Howard, Robert - 54th Mass. Humphrey, Correl L. - 80th NY Assist. Surgeon Johnson, Richard C. 132nd NY & US Navy Leonard John H. 132nd NY World War II Leonard, Morris - 11th NY Fire Zouaves Lockman, Isaac - 82nd NY Killed Gettysburg Dragovich, George N. - USAF, Italy - KIA Lockman, John (Jack) - 82nd NY - Wounded Klein, George A. 51st Armored Inf. KIA
Parisian, Genaro A. - USAF
McCormace, L. Snyder, Henry - 31st NJ - Musician Honorable Calvin Decker Van Name Taylor, Matthew - 35th NY 3rd Staten Island Borough President
Turner, George - 132nd NY who served during WWI Van Pelt, Andrew - 132nd NY Westerfield, Horatio - 12th NY Young, Henry A. - 1st NY Calvary
Erected by Friends

Photographed by Devry Becker Jones (CC0), April 19, 2025
2. History of Lake Cemetery Marker
The marker stands behind the fencing to the cemetery.
Topics. This memorial is listed in these topic lists: Cemeteries & Burial Sites • Immigration • Military • Religion & Religious Structures. A significant historical date for this entry is January 25, 1842.
Location. 40° 37.488′ N, 74° 8.717′ W. Memorial is on Staten Island, New York, in Richmond County. It is on Mid Island. It is on Forest Avenue east of Willow Road East, on the right when traveling east. Touch for map. Memorial is at or near this postal address: 1686 Forest Ave, Staten Island NY 10302, United States of America. Touch for directions.
Regionally, this memorial is in New York City. It is also in the American Mid-Atlantic. Globally, it is in the North Atlantic Region, the Western Hemisphere, and the Anglosphere. Historically, it finds itself in what was once one of the original Thirteen Colonies.
Other nearby markers. At least 8 other markers are within walking distance of this marker: Egbert Square (within shouting distance of this marker); The Bayonne Bridge (approx. half a mile away); Port Richmond (approx. 0.6 miles away); Neighborhoods & People (approx. 0.7 miles away); Westerleigh Park

Photographed by Devry Becker Jones (CC0), April 19, 2025
3. Signage for Lake/Silvie's Cemetery
Staten Island
Lake/Silvie's Cemetery
Earliest known burial 1842
Credits. This page was last revised on April 26, 2025. It was originally submitted on April 26, 2025, by Devry Becker Jones of Washington, District of Columbia. This page has been viewed 297 times since then and 103 times this year. Photos: 1, 2, 3. submitted on April 26, 2025, by Devry Becker Jones of Washington, District of Columbia.
